Menu
Thekabarnews.com Thekabarnews.com
  • Home
  • World
  • Indonesia
  • Biz & Tech
  • Islamic
  • Knowledge
  • Kabar Film
  • Kalbar
  • Opinion
  • Support Us
Thekabarnews.com Thekabarnews.com
Support Us
Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Indonesia
  • Biz & Tech
  • Islamic
  • Knowledge
  • Kabar Film
  • Kalbar
  • Opinion
  • Support Us
Let's Donate
Asset Forfeiture Law clears house after 18-year wait
Prabowo says APEC deals could reach $86.8 billion
Sherly, Amran or Anies: Who fits Indonesia’s VP role?
Home/Indonesia/Four Pillars Quiz Final sparks public backlash over alleged inconsistent judging
Indonesia

Four Pillars Quiz Final sparks public backlash over alleged inconsistent judging

JAKARTA, Thekabarnews.com—The 2026 Final Round of the Four Pillars Quiz Competition, organized by the People’s Consultative Assembly of the Republic of Indonesia (MPR RI), has attracted a lot of...

Avishiena Arch
May 12, 2026 2 Min Read
314 0
Four Pillars Quiz Final sparks public backlash over alleged inconsistent judging

JAKARTA, Thekabarnews.com—The 2026 Final Round of the Four Pillars Quiz Competition, organized by the People’s Consultative Assembly of the Republic of Indonesia (MPR RI), has attracted a lot of public attention. The incident happened after a viral video triggered criticism over the alleged inconsistencies in the judging process.

The organizers intended the competition to serve as an educational platform that strengthens national values and constitutional understanding. Instead, it became the center of controversy when netizens questioned the fairness of the judges’ scoring.

The criticism started after a video clip of a heated exchange between participants and judges in the final round became viral on social media.

The question was concerning the selection mechanism of the members of the Supreme Audit Agency (BPK).

Team C responded that the House of Representatives (DPR) chooses BPK members with input from the Regional Representative Council (DPD). They are then officially appointed by the president.

The answer was wrong; Judge Dyastasita WB, head of the Bureau of Constitutional Studies, immediately deducted five points from the team.

But then the question was asked of Team B, and the response caused some controversy.

Team B then gave what the viewers saw as an identical answer. This time the judges said it was correct and awarded 10 points.

The same answer gave inconsistent results, leading to direct complaints from Team C. They argued that the scoring was not fair or consistent.

The judging panel stuck to its original decision despite the objection.

“The final decision is up to the judging panel,” Dyastasita said in the viral video.

The issue got more attention when another judge, Indri Wahyuni, stated that articulation and clarity of speech also played an important role in the scoring.

She said if judges could not clearly hear a participant’s answer, points could be deducted for that.

“We issued that warning from the beginning. It is important to articulate. They must be able to articulate clearly,” Indri said.

Her statement provoked an even greater public outcry.

Many netizens said an academic quiz competition should be based on the correctness of answers rather than on subjective elements like speaking style. This is especially important when the answer is correct in substance.

Critics viewed the explanation as problematic for transparency and professionalism in the judging process. Social media comments quickly turned nasty.

“Terrible, a quiz competition where the judges themselves are not careful,” one X user wrote.

Another user criticized the panel, saying that the judges should have just admitted the mistake instead of defending an inconsistent decision.

Others said the judges were blaming the participants for poor diction. However, the problem was really with the panel’s inability to listen to the speech carefully.

The incident has triggered a wider discussion on fairness, accountability, and professionalism in national academic competitions, particularly those held under major state institutions.

The video continues to circulate as many are demanding clearer standards of judging and greater transparency. The public raised these demands to ensure trust remains strong in educational competitions meant to promote national values.

Tags:

factsFeaturedFour Pillars Quiz FinalindonesiaJudge Dyastasita WBMPR RINewsstory

Share Article

Palm oil revenue falls mining dominates DPR highlights Kalbar economic concerns
Previous Post

Palm oil revenue falls, mining dominates: DPR highlights Kalbar economic concerns

Dyastasita WB becomes national spotlight after Four Pillars Quiz judging controversy
Next Post

Dyastasita WB becomes national spotlight after Four Pillars Quiz judging controversy

No Comment! Be the first one.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow
34,470
fans
12,000
followers
8,200
join
50,654
subscribe
Hashim leads COP31 diplomacy as Indonesia secures Rp1.8tn | The Kabar News
Hashim leads COP31 diplomacy as Indonesia...
Kang Nchus
West Kalimantan records 1,230 Chikungunya cases | The Kabar News
West Kalimantan records 1,230 Chikungunya cases
Avishiena Arch
Indonesian govt weighs vape ban amid narcotics findings | The Kabar News
Indonesian govt weighs vape ban amid...
Achmed Eirham
Ferry Irwandi fundraiser faces transparency test | The Kabar News
Ferry Irwandi fundraiser faces transparency test
Achmed Eirham
MPR names Bambang Pacul to lead VP selection panel | The Kabar News
MPR names Bambang Pacul to lead...
Kang Nchus
MPR names Bambang Pacul to lead VP selection panel | The Kabar News
MPR names Bambang Pacul to lead...
Kang Nchus
Indonesia delays vice presidential vote to Dec. 9 | The Kabar News
Indonesia delays vice presidential vote to...
Kang Nchus
BGN appoints ex-KPK officials to oversee MBG program | The Kabar News
BGN appoints ex-KPK officials to oversee...
Avishiena Arch
Prabowo: ASEAN-China ties need peace, shared growth | The Kabar News
Prabowo: ASEAN-China ties need peace, shared...
Avishiena Arch
Prabowo vows to defy pressure in economic reform push | The Kabar News
Prabowo vows to defy pressure in...
Kang Nchus

You Might Also Like

Asset Forfeiture Law clears house after 18-year wait | The Kabar News
Indonesia
Asset Forfeiture Law clears house after 18-year wait
By Achmed Eirham
Prabowo says APEC deals could reach $86.8 billion | The Kabar News
Indonesia
Prabowo says APEC deals could reach $86.8 billion
By Kang Nchus
Sherly, Amran or Anies: Who fits Indonesia’s VP role? | The Kabar News
Knowledge
Sherly, Amran or Anies: Who fits Indonesia’s VP role?
By Achmed Eirham
Indonesia-China MoUs target $71.8bn in projects | The Kabar News
Indonesia
Indonesia-China MoUs target $71.8bn in projects
By Kusnadi Assaini
Thekabarnews.com Thekabarnews.com

Links

  • Home
  • Advertise
  • Support Us

Contact

  • About
  • Contact
  • Editorial

Follow

Instagram
Tiktok
Facebook

Our Policy

  • Cyber Media Guidelines
  • Correction Policy
  • AI Policy
Sign Up for Free and be the First to Get Notified About New Posts.
Copyright © 2026 - thekabarnews, All Right Reserved
  • Privacy Policy
  • Code Ethics
  • Disclaimer